Get Started
Get Started
570-558-0290

As discussed last week in Part I of Cervical Pillows, studies on cervical or neck pillows have shown that those using a cervical pillow demonstrated a significant reduction in chronic neck pain and headaches. However, researchers cautioned that there are many different types of pillows and that, depending on the individual; some may be more effective than others. This week, I offer tips on choosing the best pillow for you.

  1. Get a Diagnosis –
    • If possible, visit your physician to find out why you have neck pain and headaches. For example, those with arthritis, osteoporosis, degenerative disk disease or other bone and joint problems have great difficulty finding a comfortable position to sleep due to pain, stiffness and headaches upon waking up in the morning and may benefit from a proper pillow.
  2. Try it Out in the Store -
    • Cervical or neck pillows are designed to provide support specifically to the cervical or neck area of the spine. In theory, the pillow attempts to align and support the natural shape of the neck while one is sleeping.
  3. One Size Does Not Fit All -
    • A traditional pillow is often designed as a one-size-fits-all rectangle that is more about form than function. Imagine that small-framed women (5 feet tall, weighing 100 pounds) may use the same pillow as a large male football player (6 feet 5 inches, weighing 350 pounds). It is obvious that these two individuals have very different head, neck and shoulder sizes and therefore require two very different pillows.  
  4. Age Matters –
    • Ages 16 to 40 have flexible and hydrated discs and benefit more from a contour pillow with a bump, core or butterfly shape. A thinner pillow that allows the neck to extend and distract while sleeping is helpful. Ages 65 and older often have arthritic and dehydrated discs with a more rigid spine and benefit more from a thicker pillow with comfortable material such as synthetic down or memory foam to keep the neck in a slightly elevated and flexed position to avoid hyperextension. Ages 40 to 65 are in between and may need to experiment with pillows that allow extension, flexion or neutral.  
  5. Special Circumstances –
    • There are exceptions to every rule. For example, those with allergies should always ask for hypoallergic materials. Those with respiratory conditions or hiatal hernias often require elevation for comfortable sleeping. Try an 8-to-10-inch wedge to elevate the head and chest with a full pillow.
  6. Standard Filled Pillows –
    • These pillows can be filled with hard or soft materials such as synthetic or real down and resemble a more traditional-looking pillow. They allow for individual manipulation and shaping.
  7. Memory Foam Pillow -
    • This unique material offers individualized support for almost all body types. However, it is expensive (there are cheap versions) and it retains heat, so it is warm in the summer. This type may not be suitable for very small-framed individuals may not be able to compress the material and fail to find benefit. (www.tempurpedic.com), (www.thergear.com).
  8. Contour Pillow –
    • These ergonomically designed pillows are contoured to support the “hollow” of the neck with a “bump” or “core.” Some offer a cut out for the side sleeper such as the” butterfly” pillow. They work best for younger, more flexible spines and small-framed people. Contour pillows can be found at: (www.coreproducts.com),  (www.bodyline.com).
  9. Travel Pillow –
    • These pillows offer proper support to prevent your head from bobbing up and down while sleeping in a car or on a airplane. Most are horseshoe collar shaped and I am partial to the inflatable version from BrookstoneR  due to its portability (www.brookstone.com).
  10. Keep Trying -
    • It is important to remember, there is no one pillow fit for everyone…they are unique to each person. Pillow type should be based on body type, head size, shoulder width, favorite position of sleep and medical conditions. Always try to sample a cheaper version of a product when possible.  

EVERY MONDAY – Read Dr. Paul J. Mackarey “Health & Exercise Forum!” via Blog

EVERY SUNDAY in "The Sunday Times" - Read Dr. Paul J. Mackarey “Health & Exercise Forum!” in hard copy

This article is not intended as a substitute for medical treatment. If you have questions related to your medical condition, please contact your family physician. For further inquires related to this topic email: drpmackarey@msn.com

Paul J. Mackarey PT, DHSc, OCS is a Doctor in Health Sciences specializing in orthopedic and sports physical therapy in Scranton and Clarks Summit. Dr. Mackarey is in private practice and is an associate professor of clinical medicine at Geisinger Commonwealth School of Medicine. For all of Dr. Mackarey's articles, visit our exercise forum!

Are you one of the millions of people who suffer from chronic neck (cervical) pain and headaches? Did you ever wonder if your pillow is right for you? Studies on cervical or neck pillows have shown that those with chronic neck pain showed a significant reduction in neck pain and headaches when using a cervical pillow for four weeks when compared to the control group. However, there are many types of cervical pillows, and there is no single best choice for everyone. This column will give you an overview of the different types of cervical pillows, and hopefully this information will help guide you to the right pillow for your individual size and shape.  

Introduction:

People who suffer from back and neck pain are always in search of something to lessen their pain and stiffness. Those with conditions such as arthritis, osteoporosis, or other bone and joint problems have great difficulty finding a comfortable position to sleep, and they often wake up with pain, stiffness and headaches in the morning. For these people, a cervical pillow may offer great comfort, because it is specifically designed to alleviate these symptoms.

Traditional pillows have drawbacks mainly because they are designed as a one-size-fits-all rectangle with greater emphasis placed on form than on function. Very often, a small-framed woman (5 feet tall, weighing 100 pounds) may find herself using the same style of pillow as a large male with the build of a football player (6 feet 5 inches weighing 350 pounds). It is obvious these two individuals have very different head, neck and shoulder sizes, and therefore they require two very different types of pillows.  

Cervical or neck pillows come in a variety of shapes and sizes, and they are designed to provide support specifically to the cervical area of the spine. In theory, a cervical pillow attempts to align and support the natural shape of the neck while one is sleeping. Those suffering from neck or shoulder pain, degenerative cervical disc disease, or conditions such as arthritis or osteoporosis may find these pillows valuable.

Types of Pillows:

Cervical pillows are made by many different manufacturers and come in a variety of sizes, designs and shapes. Manufacturers claim that these pillows offer the benefits of increased circulation, improved breathing, reduced snoring and lessened neck and shoulder muscle pain and stiffness. One manufacturer, Tempur-PedicR (www.tempurpedic.com), boasts special memory foam technology that, they claim, offers unique and individualized support to accommodate the weight of every body type.

When selecting a cervical pillow, it is important to remember several things. First, know that most manufacturer claims are not subject to validation by independent research studies. Second, remember that, regardless of what a manufacturer states, no single pillow is right for every person. Third, realize that the most expensive option is not necessarily the best. Although many people consider Tempur-PedicR to be the leader in the field, they are costly, ranging from $89 to $349. If you shop around, you can find several companies that offer alternatives—both of similar and alternative designs—that may actually be a better fit for your neck and your budget.

Other companies producing cervical pillows include CoreR, which offers support around the periphery with a special or dip (or “core”) in the middle in which your head rests (www.coreproducts.com),  MediflowR, which offers a water pillow with multiple options and BodyLineR, which offers a model with both a large and a small orthopedic “bump” in one pillow (www.bodyline.com). These pillows are economical, ranging in price from $35 to $100.

Regardless of what brand of pillow you select, it is likely to fall into one of the following three categories:

Conclusion:

It is important to remember that there is no one pillow fit for everyone, each person’s needs are unique. You should select your pillow type based on your body type, head size, shoulder width, favorite sleeping position, and medical conditions, such as neck or lower back pain, osteoarthritis, headaches, etc. When choosing a pillow, try to sample a cheaper version of the product when possible. For example, if you think you might like the “orthopedic bump” style from Tempur-PedicR that costs $200, consider trying the $50-60 version from TherGearR first. Better yet, if you have a friend or relative with a similar body type and problem who successfully uses a cervical pillow, try borrowing it! Finding the right pillow is a process of trial-and-error, so not get frustrated or give up. If you succeed in finding the right pillow for you, the result will be worth the search.

EVERY MONDAY – Read Dr. Paul J. Mackarey “Health & Exercise Forum!” via Blog

EVERY SUNDAY in "The Sunday Times" - Read Dr. Paul J. Mackarey “Health & Exercise Forum!” in hard copy - Next Week, Part II of II: Tips to Select a Good Cervical Pillow For You.

This article is not intended as a substitute for medical treatment. If you have questions related to your medical condition, please contact your family physician. For further inquires related to this topic email: drpmackarey@msn.com

Paul J. Mackarey PT, DHSc, OCS is a Doctor in Health Sciences specializing in orthopedic and sports physical therapy in Scranton and Clarks Summit. Dr. Mackarey is in private practice and is an associate professor of clinical medicine at Geisinger Commonwealth School of Medicine. For all of Dr. Mackarey's articles, visit our exercise forum!Next Week, Part II of II: Tips to Select a Good Cervical Pillow For You.

Recently, a young woman came to my office with complaints of severe middle and lower back pain. On her first visit, I noticed her beautiful pink purse (big bag) and asked her permission to weigh the bag and discovered that it weighed 8 pounds. While 8 pounds does not seem excessive, the woman weighed 120 pounds and based on the research, would be advised to carry a 2.5-to-3.5-pound bag, (2-3% of her body weight).

A recent study shows that the average weight of a woman’s purse has increased by 38% and now exceeds 6 pounds. Despite technological advances, women have not found a way to simplify their lives, or at least what they think they need in their lives. High tech gadgets have only added weight to a purse already filled to the brim.

On a whim, I decided to ask permission to examine the contents of some of my patient’s purses. A typical purse includes the following: hairbrush, cosmetic bag, mirror, feminine products, keys, and sunglasses, reading glasses, checkbook, wallet, coupons, water bottle, and medications. Additionally, I discovered heavy high-tech products such as cellular phones, tablets, digital Bluetooth earpieces, and rechargers. Lastly, some women add the weight of a book or Kindle to the bag. Studies also show that the larger the bag and stronger the straps, the more items are stuffed in, resulting in a very heavy purse.

It is a pervasive attitude that a woman should never be stranded without her purse full of essentials. So, where is the problem? The problem is that carrying a heavy bag, usually on one side of the body, forces the body to tilt forward and to the opposite direction to compensate. Over time, this change in posture leads to neck, middle and lower back pain.

SIGNS THAT YOUR PURSE IS TOO HEAVY:

Consider the following suggestions to promote healthy use of a purse and prevent injury:

10 Suggestions:

EVERY MONDAY – Read Dr. Paul J. Mackarey “Health & Exercise Forum!” via Blog

EVERY SUNDAY in "The Sunday Times" - Read Dr. Paul J. Mackarey “Health & Exercise Forum!” in hard copy

This article is not intended as a substitute for medical treatment. If you have questions related to your medical condition, please contact your family physician. For further inquires related to this topic email: drpmackarey@msn.com

Paul J. Mackarey PT, DHSc, OCS is a Doctor in Health Sciences specializing in orthopedic and sports physical therapy in Scranton and Clarks Summit. Dr. Mackarey is in private practice and is an associate professor of clinical medicine at Geisinger Commonwealth School of Medicine. For all of Dr. Mackarey's articles, visit our exercise forum!

June is migraine and headache awareness month! According to the World Health Organization about half of the world’s adult population has had a headache at least once in the past year. Prolonged use of electronic devices has greatly contributed to this problem. For many people, these headaches are infrequent and do not often affect daily life.  But what about when your headache occurs frequently or is so severe it prevents you from going about your day to day activities? Some types of headaches are more easily treated and managed than others.

There are two types of headaches: primary and secondary. Primary headaches occur without an underlying disease and include migraines and tension-type headaches.  Secondary headaches can be associated with serious disease, requiring emergency care, or can be referred from other structures of the body such as the cervical spine (neck). 

Headaches symptoms that may constitute a medical emergency are: vomiting, seizures, fever, muscle pain, night sweat, weight loss, and neurologic symptoms such as blurred vision.  If you are experiencing any of these symptoms, if your headache worsens, or your symptoms change it is recommended that you seek medical attention. Any headache that is unusual for you and does not resolve itself in a reasonable time should be brought to your primary care physician’s attention.

Primary Headaches:

Migraines: Migraines are a primary form of headache that typically lasts from four to seventy two hours, can range from moderate to severe pain, and typically are located on only one side of the head.  Often they can be accompanied by an aura, nausea or vomiting, sensitivity to sound, or light sensitivity.  Migraines can be aggravated by routine physical activity such as going up stairs. This type of headache is thought to occur in the central nervous system.

Tension-type: Tension-type headaches are the most common primary headache disorder and can last anywhere from thirty minutes to seven days.  These can often have a pressing or tightening quality that occurs on both sides of the head.  Typically, there is no nausea, vomiting, or aggravation with physical activity, however, light or sound sensitivity can occur. This type of headache is thought to occur in the central nervous system but can have a hereditary component and is usually associated with muscle tender points. Tension – type headaches can be treated with relaxation techniques such as Progressive Muscle Relaxation (PMR), medications, and physical therapy.

Secondary Headaches:

The most common secondary headache that is not related to a serious medical condition is a cervicogenic headache (originating from the neck).

Cervicogenic Headache: The length of time a cervicogenic headache can last varies.  Here the pain is on one side and usually starts in the neck.  This type of headache is aggravated or preceded by head postures or movements of the neck.  Due to the nerves of the neck and face sharing common connections, pain signals sent from one region can lead to discomfort in the other.  Physical therapy can be an effective treatment to help relieve symptoms. For example: posture, exercise, ergonomics, massage, manual techniques, traction, trigger point, and acupressure.

A cervicogenic headache can be caused by an accident or trauma or can stem from neck movement or sustained postures.  Sustained postures could mean sitting in front of a computer at work or looking down at your phone.  Changing these postures throughout the day could help reduce symptoms.  Changing postures could mean bringing your phone closer to you using pillows or another supportive surface when reading or checking social media.  If you are someone who works at a desk, it could involve taking breaks or getting a standing desk.  However your life requires you to move, there are some simple and effective exercises you can perform throughout the day to help cervicogenic headache symptoms.

TIPS FOR TENSION HEADACHES:

Progressive Muscle Relaxation: PMR is an effective method for reducing tension throughout the body.  With this method you first tense a muscle group, such as at the neck or shoulder, and then relax the muscles noting the difference between the two.  This helps reduce both stress and tension. For more information or to learn how to do PMR, refer to podcast at: https://www.psychologies.co.uk/try-progressive-muscle-relaxation

Manage your stress level: While stressors vary from person to person, one method for managing stress is with exercise.  Any form of exercise can help reduce stress, but a cost free method is aerobic exercise such as walking or running.  A less time consuming method could be to perform deep breathing exercises throughout the day.

Heat or cold: When feeling sore or stiff, applying a hot or cold pack or taking a hot shower can help ease a tension headache. 

Posture: Some tips for posture are to make sure your head is over your shoulders rather than sitting forward and making sure you are sitting or standing up straight with your shoulders back. 

Over the counter medications: Talk to your doctor or pharmacist for additional information.

5 TIPS FOR CERVICAL HEADACHES:

Posture: See tips listed under tension headaches.

Ergonomics: If your job or hobbies require you to sit for extended periods it may be beneficial to change positions throughout the day or consider getting a standing desk. Also, limit time on electronic devices. When sitting make sure the monitor is at eye level, your legs are able to fit under your desk, and you are close to the keyboard and monitor.  If you are working with a laptop or phone, avoid putting it on your lap. Instead, bring your laptop closer to you by putting pillows on your lap or using an ergonomic desktop. See photo below.

Exercise: Some exercises to help relieve symptoms are chin tucks, shoulder blade pinches, and back extension.  These exercises can be performed multiple times throughout the day in sitting or standing.

Physical Therapy: Physical therapy may include massage, manual techniques, stretching, traction/ decompression and exercise.  A physical therapist can assess your posture and provide strategies specific to you.

Over the counter medications: While medication may not cure cervicogenic headaches, they may help relieve pain. Talk to your doctor or pharmacist for additional information.

Visit your doctor regularly and listen to your body.

Dr. Chua is a neurologist and headache specialist at Geisinger Health System in Northeast Pennsylvania. In addition to caring for people with headache and facial pain disorders, Dr. Chua also serves as: Director of Headache Medicine at Geisinger, Clinical Director of Neurology at Geisinger Wyoming Valley, faculty at Thomas Jefferson University’s Advanced Headache Diagnosis and Management Post-Graduate Certificate Program, and Treasurer and Executive Board Member of the Association of Migraine Disorders. In her spare time, she enjoys going on adventures with her husband and toddler, learning new skills (she is now certified in battlefield acupuncture), and buying great books she will never have time to read!

EVERY MONDAY – Read Dr. Paul J. Mackarey “Health & Exercise Forum!” via Blog

EVERY SUNDAY in "The Sunday Times" - Read Dr. Paul J. Mackarey “Health & Exercise Forum!” in hard copy

This article is not intended as a substitute for medical treatment. If you have questions related to your medical condition, please contact your family physician. For further inquires related to this topic email: drpmackarey@msn.com

Paul J. Mackarey PT, DHSc, OCS is a Doctor in Health Sciences specializing in orthopaedic and sports physical therapy in Scranton and Clarks Summit. Dr. Mackarey is in private practice and is an associate professor of clinical medicine at Geisinger Commonwealth School of Medicine. For all of Dr. Mackarey's articles, visit our exercise forum!

According to the World Health Organization about half of the world’s adult population has had a headache at least once in the past year. Prolonged use of electronic devices has greatly contributed to this problem. For many people, these headaches are infrequent and do not often affect daily life.  But what about when your headache occurs frequently or is so severe it prevents you from going about your day to day activities? Some types of headaches are more easily treated and managed than others.

There are two types of headaches: primary and secondary. Primary headaches occur without an underlying disease and include migraines and tension-type headaches.  Secondary headaches can be associated with serious disease, requiring emergency care, or can be referred from other structures of the body such as the cervical spine (neck). 

Headaches symptoms that may constitute a medical emergency are: vomiting, seizures, fever, muscle pain, night sweat, weight loss, and neurologic symptoms such as blurred vision.  If you are experiencing any of these symptoms, if your headache worsens, or your symptoms change it is recommended that you seek medical attention. Any headache that is unusual for you and does not resolve itself in a reasonable time should be brought to your primary care physician’s attention.

Primary Headaches:

Migraines: Migraines are a primary form of headache that typically lasts from four to seventy two hours, can range from moderate to severe pain, and typically are located on only one side of the head.  Often they can be accompanied by an aura, nausea or vomiting, sensitivity to sound, or light sensitivity.  Migraines can be aggravated by routine physical activity such as going up stairs. This type of headache is thought to occur in the central nervous system and is related to blood vessels.

Tension-type: Tension-type headaches are the most common primary headache disorder and can last anywhere from thirty minutes to seven days.  These can often have a pressing or tightening quality that occurs on both sides of the head.  Here there is no nausea, vomiting, light sensitivity, or aggravation with physical activity. This type of headache is thought to occur in the central nervous system but can have a hereditary component and is usually associated with muscle tender points. Tension – type headaches can be treated with relaxation techniques such as Progressive Muscle Relaxation (PMR), medications, and physical therapy.

Secondary Headaches:

The most common secondary headache that is not related to a serious medical condition is a cervicogenic headache (originating from the neck).

Cervicogenic Headache: The length of time a cervicogenic headache can last varies.  Here the pain is on one side and usually starts in the neck.  This type of headache is aggravated or preceded by head postures or movements of the neck.  Due to the nerves of the neck and face sharing common connections, pain signals sent from one region can lead to discomfort in the other.  Physical therapy can be an effective treatment to help relieve symptoms. For example: posture, exercise, ergonomics, massage, manual techniques, traction, trigger point, and acupressure.

A cervicogenic headache can be caused by an accident or trauma or can stem from neck movement or sustained postures.  Sustained postures could mean sitting in front of a computer at work or looking down at your phone.  Changing these postures throughout the day could help reduce symptoms.  Changing postures could mean bringing your phone closer to you using pillows or another supportive surface when reading or checking social media.  If you are someone who works at a desk, it could involve taking breaks or getting a standing desk.  However your life requires you to move, there are some simple and effective exercises you can perform throughout the day to help cervicogenic headache symptoms.

5 TIPS FOR TENSION HEADACHES

Progressive Muscle Relaxation: PMR is an effective method for reducing tension throughout the body.  With this method you first tense a muscle group, such as at the neck or shoulder, and then relax the muscles noting the difference between the two.  This helps reduce both stress and tension. For more information or to learn how to do PMR, refer to podcast at: https://www.psychologies.co.uk/try-progressive-muscle-relaxation

Manage your stress level: While stressors vary from person to person, one method for managing stress is with exercise.  Any form of exercise can help reduce stress, but a cost free method is aerobic exercise such as walking or running.  A less time consuming method could be to perform deep breathing exercises throughout the day.

Heat or cold: When feeling sore or stiff, applying a hot or cold pack or taking a hot shower can help ease a tension headache. 

Posture: Some tips for posture are to make sure your head is over your shoulders rather than sitting forward and making sure you are sitting or standing up straight with your shoulders back. 

Over the counter medications: Talk to your doctor or pharmacist for additional information.

5 TIPS FOR CERVICAL HEADACHES

Posture: See tips listed under tension headaches.

Ergonomics: If your job or hobbies require you to sit for extended periods it may be beneficial to change positions throughout the day or consider getting a standing desk. Also, limit time on electronic devices. When sitting make sure the monitor is at eye level, your legs are able to fit under your desk, and you are close to the keyboard and monitor.  If you are working with a laptop or phone, avoid putting it on your lap. Instead, bring your laptop closer to you by putting pillows on your lap.

Exercise: Some exercises to help relieve symptoms are chin tucks, shoulder blade pinches, and back extension.  These exercises can be performed multiple times throughout the day in sitting or standing.

Physical Therapy: Physical therapy may include massage, manual techniques, stretching, traction/ decompression and exercise.  A physical therapist can assess your posture and provide strategies specific to you.

Over the counter medications: While medication may not cure cervicogenic headaches, they may help relieve pain. Talk to your doctor or pharmacist for additional information.

Contibutor: Alexa Rzucidlo, PT, DPT

NEXT MONDAY – Read Dr. Paul J. Mackarey “Health & Exercise Forum!”

This article is not intended as a substitute for medical treatment. If you have questions related to your medical condition, please contact your family physician. For further inquires related to this topic email: drpmackarey@msn.com

Paul J. Mackarey PT, DHSc, OCS is a Doctor in Health Sciences specializing in orthopaedic and sports physical therapy. Dr. Mackarey is in private practice and is an associate professor of clinical medicine at Geisinger Commonwealth School of Medicine (formerly The Commonwealth Medical College).

Holiday shopping is stressful to your body as well as your wallet. Driving from store to store, getting in and out of the car, bundled in a sweater and winter coat, the expert shopper carries package after package from the store, to the car, over and over again. Six, eight, or ten hours later, the shopper arrives home exhausted, only to realize that 15, or 20 packages must be carried from the car into the house. This dilemma is compounded by the fact that the rain turned to sleet, and the sleet to snow. Travel by car and foot are treacherous. You are slipping and sliding all the way from the car to the house while carrying multiple packages of various sizes and shapes. The shopping bags get wet and tear, forcing you to tilt your body as you carry the packages. Of course, no one is home to help you unload the car and you make the trip several times alone. You get into the house exhausted and crash onto the couch. You fall asleep slouched and slumped in an overstuffed pillow chair. Hours later you wake up with a stiff neck and lower back pain. You wonder what happened to your neck and back. Consider the following:

Other Tips:

Plan Ahead: It is very stressful on your spirit, wallet and back to do all of your shopping in the three weeks available after Thanksgiving. Even though we dislike “rushing” past Thanksgiving to the next holiday, try to begin holiday shopping in before 

Use the Internet: Supporting local businesses is important. However, Internet shopping can save you lots of wear and tear. Sometimes, you can even get a gift wrapped.

Gift Certificates: While gift certificates may be impersonal, they are easy, convenient and can also be purchased over the internet.

Perform Stretching Exercises: Chin Tucks, Shoulder Blade Pinch, Back Extension. Stretch intermittently throughout the shopping day…try the three exercises below, gently, slowly, hold 3 seconds and relax, repeat 5 times.

NEXT MONDAY – Read Dr. Paul J. Mackarey “Health & Exercise Forum!”  

This article is not intended as a substitute for medical treatment. If you have questions related to your medical condition, please contact your family physician. For further inquires related to this topic email: drpmackarey@msn.com

For all of Dr. Mackarey's Articles visit: mackareyphysicaltherapy.com/forum

Paul J. Mackarey PT, DHSc, OCS is a Doctor in Health Sciences specializing in orthopaedic and sports physical therapy. Dr. Mackarey is in private practice and is an associate professor of clinical medicine at Geisinger Commonwealth School of Medicine.

HEALTH AND EXERCISE FORUM

By: Dr. Paul J. Mackarey

This column is a monthly feature of “Health & Exercise Forum” in association with the students and faculty of Geisinger Commonwealth School of Medicine (formerly The Commonwealth Medical College).

Heat vs. Cold

Guest Columnist: Kevin Perry, MD

“Should I use heat or ice?” Several years ago, while working as a third year medical student at TCMC on orthopedic rotation, I was surprised to find that this is one of the most common questions asked by weekend warriors trying to relieve shoulder pain after playing tennis for the first time in 6 months. Now, as an orthopedic resident, the frequency of this inquiry has not changed. Trying to decide whether to use ice or heat to make it feel better and heal faster may not be so easy. Unfortunately, there is confusion, even among medical professionals, about the appropriate times to use  heat or cold. However, if we review the basic science on this subject, there are some valuable guidelines to consider.

The Science

When an injury is sustained, such as a sprained ankle, chemical signals are released in the area of the injury, which increases blood supply to the damaged tissues to allow appropriate cells to repair the damage. This response is evident by the principle signs and symptoms of inflammation including heat, redness, swelling, pain, and loss of function. This reaction makes sense because anytime tissues are injured; the body is responsible to protect the site until repair can occur. To protect the injured site, the body causes swelling and pain to prevent excessive movement or overuse which will lead to further injury. With the site of injury protected, the appropriate cells are able to lay down new tissue to repair the damage. As tissues heal, a web of connective tissue pulls the damaged tissues back together and holds them in place while new tissue is formed. Once the tissue is completely repaired, the blood flow returns to normal and fluid drains from the site of injury allowing restoration of motion and function. However, the new tissue is fragile and unorganized and often sticks together leaving tightness and weakness. After repeated use, the new tissue adapts to the stress placed upon it and becomes functional.

The Application

When grounded in science, the use of heat or cold can be used to expedite the healing process. While inflammation is crucial to the repair of injured tissue, the response can be exaggerated and last longer than necessary. Therefore, ice and heat can be used to modify the bodies’ inflammatory response and help us return to activity sooner.

How Cold Works

Ice causes blood vessels to narrow and nerves to slow down. When ice is applied to tissue, the body responds by decreasing blood flow to the area to preserve the core body temperature. Also, as nerves cool down, the signals they send slow down and become less frequent, so the pain signals they send to your brain become less intense. Thus, we can use ice to decrease blood flow to inflamed tissue which will reduce swelling and decrease pain. Ice is ideally used immediately following most injuries to control pain and swelling.

How Heat Works

Heat causes your blood vessels to open and increase blood flow to tissues. When heat is applied, blood flow and tissue temperature are increased and tight tissues relax and are better able to glide across one another. However, when applied too early in the healing process, heat, by increasing blood flow, can increase swelling and pain. Heat is ideally used after an injury has healed and there is residual tightness or protective muscle spasms. 

Now that we know how ice and heat work in conjunction with the inflammatory process we can easily understand when to use each one. Ice is best used following an acute injury. For example, ice is effective day one through three following an ankle sprain, or until swelling is controlled. Anytime the principle signs and symptoms of inflammation are present, ice is the appropriate treatment of choice. Regardless of when the injury occurred, if there is swelling and pain, ice is the appropriate treatment.   Heat should be used when there is tightness and stiffness and no signs of acute inflammation. For example, week two of three, following an ankle sprain if stiffness persists and swelling is controlled.

How To…

Apply ice using a bag of ice and water, ice pack, or bag of frozen vegetables wrapped in a wet towel. Cover the injured and swollen area and if possible elevate the iced area above the level of your heart. You should apply ice for a maximum of 20 minutes and rest at least one hour between icing sessions so as not to cause harm. Never apply ice directly to skin and never fall asleep while icing.

Apply heat with a heating pad covered in a few towels or warm a bag of rice in a microwave. Cover in a towel and place the heat on the affected area for a maximum of 20 minutes and rest at least one hour between heating sessions. Never apply heat over skin that you cannot feel (numbness or loss of sensation) or on open wounds in the skin. Also, do not lie directly on the heating source and don’t fall asleep while using heat to avoid burns.

Hopefully this information is helpful in dispelling some of the confusion regarding when to use ice or heat. As you can see there is no “golden rule” or “72-hour rule” for advising when to use ice or heat. But if you stick to the principles discussed in this article, you should be treating your aches and pains appropriately. This has been a simplified explanation of a complex topic and if you have any further questions, please ask a medical professional.

Top Reasons for use of Ice (Cryotherapy):

Top Reasons for use of Heat (Thermotherapy):

  • - Chronic Stable Low Back Pain  (Example: Healed Lumbar Strain)
  • - Postural Neck Pain (Example: Trigger Points)
  • - Prior to exercise/activity (Example: Rehabilitation)
  • - Osteoarthritis with stiffness (Example: Morning stiffness)
  • - Muscle Spasms (Example: Overuse)

Kevin Perry, MD graduated from The Commonwealth Medical College (GCSOM) in 2015. He is a resident in Orthopaedic Surgery at LSU Health Science Center Shreveport and will be moving back to Pennsylvania next month to pursuit a fellowship in orthopedic trauma at Penn State Health Milton S Hershey Medical Center. His special interests include pelvis and acetabulum trauma, complex periarticular fractures, malunions, nonunions, and deformity correction. Dr Perry completed his undergraduate education at Loyola University Maryland and graduate degree (doctor of physical therapy) at the University of Scranton.

Read all of Dr. Mackarey's articles in the Health and Exercise Forum at our website: https://mackareyphysicaltherapy.com/forum/

Read “Health & Exercise Forum” – Every Monday.  This article is not intended as a substitute for medical treatment. If you have questions related to your medical condition, please contact your family physician. For further inquires related to this topic email: drpmackarey@msn.com

Paul J. Mackarey PT, DHSc, OCS is a Doctor  in Health Sciences specializing in orthopaedic and sports physical therapy. Dr. Mackarey is in private practice and is an associate professor of clinical medicine at GCSOM.

Part II of II

I think we would all agree, technology is a wonderful thing. However, like all good things, it comes at a price. Students and workers alike are suffering from the many physical effects of sitting for too many hours...especially with COVID-19 home confinement! Studies show the impact of prolonged sitting, especially with poor posture, are multifaceted: pain, headaches, vision problems, poor concentration, excess fat storage with weight gain. Studies strongly support the use of using good posture, ergonomic workstations, posture stretches and frequent changes of positions, including the use of standing desks to prevent pain and injury as we discussed last week in part I.

The Problem is Gravity!

The average head weighs 10 to 12 pounds and when tilted down at a 45 degree angle the forces of gravity are multiplied by 5. While reading, studying or working on the computer with poor posture, one must support 50 or more pounds of pressure on the neck, middle and lower back for hours on end. It is no wonder why this activity is associated with headaches, neck and back pain, numbness and tingling in arms and legs, muscle spasms etc.  Some studies report the lifetime prevalence of neck and shoulder pain in office workers as high as 80%.

Spine problems can be prevented with good posture and proper body mechanics. Poor posture and improper body mechanics subject the spine to abnormal stresses that, over time, can lead to degeneration and pain. Good posture and proper body mechanics and frequent changes in positions, can minimize current spine pain and prevent recurrent episodes. Posture is the position in which you hold your body upright against gravity. Good posture involves positions that place the least amount of stress on the spine. Good posture maintains the spine in a “neutral” position. In a neutral spine, the three normal curves are preserved (a small hollow at the base of the neck, a small roundness at the midback and a small hollow in the low back). When viewed from the side, the upper back appears straight with a small hollow in the lower back.

GOOD POSTURE

Standing: Feet should be shoulder width apart. Distribute body weight evenly through both feet. Do not lock knees. Maintain a small hollow in lower back with “tailbone” slightly tucked down. Lift the breastbone by drawing shoulder blades back and down. Make chin level. Earlobes should be in line with the middle of shoulders. Relax jaw and neck muscles by resting tongue on the roof of mouth.

Sitting: Sit in a firm, high-back, straight-back chair. Buttocks should touch the back of chair while maintaining a small space between the back of knees and the seat of the chair. Distribute body weight evenly on both hips. Maintain an arch in the low back. A lumbar roll is recommended. It is a foam roll, 4” to 5” in diameter and 12” long, placed at belt level. Place feet flat on the floor with hips and knees bent at a right angle. Keep knees even with or slightly higher than hips. Use a footstool or footrest if necessary. Do not cross legs! Lift the breastbone by drawing shoulder blades back and down. Earlobes should be in line with the middle of shoulders. Position the armrests properly allowing elbows and forearms to rest with shoulders relaxed. If armrests are too high shoulders will shrug up and if too low will cause slouching.

POSTURE EXERCISES

The following exercises should be performed throughout the day as a break from sitting, studying or working at home, school or the office. They should be performed gently, slowly, held for 3-5 seconds and repeated 5-10 times. The exercises should only cause a slight stretch but NOT PAIN.

CHIN TUCKS: sit or stand up straight, bring your head over your shoulders as if to make a double chin.
SHOULDER BLADE PINCH: sit or stand up straight and pinch your shoulder blades together as if rowing a boat.
STANDING EXTENSION: place your hands on your hips and bend backwards from the waist.
PRONE LYING EXTENSION: while lying on your belly, prop yourself up on your elbows and extend your back. If no stretch is felt, then extend your elbows for better stretch.
PROPER SITTING ERGONOMICS
PROPER STANDING ERGONOMICS

For all of Dr. Mackarey's Articles visit our health care forum at https://mackareyphysicaltherapy.com/forum/

Dr. Mackarey’s Health & Exercise Forum – every Monday

This article is not intended as a substitute for medical treatment. If you have questions related to your medical condition, please contact your family physician. For further inquires related to this topic email: drpmackarey@msn.com. Paul J. Mackarey PT, DHSc, OCS is a Doctor  in Health Sciences specializing in orthopaedic and sports physical therapy. Dr. Mackarey is in private practice and is an associate professor of clinical medicine at Geisinger Commonwealth School of Medicine.